SA agricultural jobs hold steady despite intense immigration debate

This story has significance for readers across Africa and beyond.

We typically tout South Africaâs farming sector as crucial for job creation. The primary farming sector employs close to a million people, and more than 300,000 additional people work in the value chains.

Looking to the future, given technological advancements, we remain convinced that as this sector expands, more jobs will be created.

Emerging labour dynamics in agriculture also demand careful attention. The immigration discourse has created the impression that South Africaâs farming sector is reeling as unharvested produce rots due to foreign workers leaving the country. However, this issue needs to be treated delicately, without exaggerations that create undue reputational risks.

Indeed, there are foreign workers in the South African farming sector, especially in the provinces bordering our neighbouring countries and in certain value chains, such as sugar cane and fruit. However, data on their share of overall farming employment are always challenging to assess. A number of these workers typically engage in the sector during the busy harvesting periods that require more labour.

Also, because the farming sector deals with perishable products, timeliness at every stage of production is key. There is a need to ensure that harvesting is not delayed, as this would affect the quality of the produce and the farming sectorâs income and long-term sustainability.

I mention this not to validate the view that products are rotting in various fields across the country, but to say that we have to manage immigration issues in farm labour carefully and ensure that legal processes are followed efficiently, as has been the case in the past and remains the case now. The Department of Home Affairs has a major role to play here, along with organised agriculture.

We also need to be careful about creating narratives that the farming sector prioritises only foreign workers, or that the sector collapsed once the immigration debate began â a claim unsupported by current conditions.

There are many South Africans who work on farms and will continue to participate in the sector, in the jobs that will be created as it expands. But in places where foreign workers are needed, we must continue the legal processes used in the past to enable such efforts and efficiencies on farms.

Stable conditions

Now, conditions are broadly stable in the South African agricultural labour market. Consider the second quarter of 2026: South Africaâs agricultural jobs were at 944,000, up 4% from a year ago. This partly captures the period when the immigration discourse had already begun and shows that the agricultural labour market remained robust.

Thus, suggesting that crops countrywide are rotting may not accurately capture the challenge and risks causing alarm about the state of agricultural labour. There are isolated cases of labour challenges (without minimising the impact on those affected), but the broader sector doesnât face them.

In surveys conducted by the Agricultural Business Chamber of South Africa and AgriSA, we found the challenge was isolated to a few provinces and industries, not widespread. Thus, the jobs data for the second quarter of the year were also still robust. But this doesnât mean there are no risks ahead.

As I said earlier, during peak harvesting periods, when farmers require labour, there are cases where foreign workers, through legal processes, join the sector for seasonal jobs. In such cases, we must have a clear path for handling this to avoid risks in the sector.

There is also a responsibility on the sector to continuously recruit as many South Africans as possible, as the government has prioritised agriculture due to its potential to help reduce the countryâs high unemployment.

Ultimately, the immigration matter is not an easy issue and will need to be handled carefully, without causing alarm or undue reputational risk to the export-oriented farming sector, as all key export markets place considerable value on farm labour practices. DM

Reporting originally appeared via Daily Maverick. Read the full source for additional context.