Manifesto test: SACPâs power to the people and a working class embraced

This story has significance for readers across Africa and beyond.

The SACP is for the first time contesting an election on its own steam outside the tripartite alliance with which it has historically been in a political pact. The ANC has insisted dual members pick sides, making this an important part of the electoral race to watch. The SACPâs manifesto is refreshingly short and principled. Its brevity, however, does reveal the absence of hard experience of governing.

1. Turn on the taps

This is one of the SACPâs strongest sections: âWater that flows. Lights that work. Streets that are cared for.â

The party promises ward-by-ward audits of water and sanitation, public maintenance plans, rapid-Âresponse teams for leaks and sewer spills, and properly staffed municipal technical units. Importantly, it explicitly shifts the emphasis from emergency response to preventative maintenance, saying it wants to end dry taps and the reliance on water tankers.

The ideological difference compared with the DA manifesto is stark: rather than concessioning or private sector participation, the SACPâs solution is to rebuild municipal capacity and insource essential work.

Verdict: There is little detail about where the capital investment required to repair ageing water infrastructure will come from, or how dysfunctional water utilities and municipalities would acquire the technical skills to do this themselves.

2. Keep the lights on

The manifesto concentrates more on affordability and public provision than on electricity generation or solving outages.

It says electricity has become âsix times more expensive in real terms since 2007â and promises âfair, pro-poor tariffsâ, protection of lifeline services and an end to âpunitive disconnections of the poorâ. Cable theft is identified later in the maniÂfesto as an attack on working-class communities and infrastructure.

Verdict: There is no substantial muniÂcipal energy plan here â little about alternative generation, grid investment, load reduction, electricity losses or how municipalities will settle debts to Eskom. That is particularly noticeable because Daily Maverickâs test specifically asks parties how they will âfix electricity, end outages and pay Eskomâ.

3. Fill the potholes

The SACP is direct: âMunicipal roads must be treated as essential public infrastructure, not as an afterthought.â

It promises the maintenance and repair of township and village roads and specifically identifies potholes, washed-away access roads and neglected streets as barriers to jobs, clinics, schools and markets.

On transport, it promises âintegrated, affordable, safe and reliable public transport under public and community controlâ, including cooperative transport initiatives.

Again, the distinguishing idea is public or community ownership, rather than contracting out.

Verdict: There are few measurable targets â no resurfacing kilometres, repair turnaround times or explanation of how failing muniÂcipal road agencies would be fixed.

4. Sort out the s***

Sanitation is folded into the water programme: ward-by-ward audits, maintenance plans and rapid-Âresponse teams for sewer spills.

There is one particularly clear commitment: âThe bucket system is a humiliation and must be eradicated.â

Informal settlements would be upgraded âwith the people, not against themâ.

Verdict: Excellent. The only manifesto weâve analysed thus far that says we shouldnât have the bucket system more than 30 years into the democratic era.

5. Light up our streets

The SACP proposes community safety forums, street and section committees, repaired streetlights and safe routes, and survivor-centred gender-based violence services. It singles out stock theft, cable theft and extortion networks, describing them as attacks on working-class livelihoods and infrastructure.

Verdict: This is less a conventional âmore metro policeâ crime plan than a community-organising model of municipal safety. And we like that.

6. Clean up our towns

This is probably the weakest fit with our test. Recycling appears as one potential component of its proposed municipal decent work plans, but there is remarkably little specific detail on refuse collection, illegal dumping, landfill management or keeping streets clean.

Verdict: This is a significant omission given how central waste collection is to municipal performance â and to our manifesto test, which specifically asks for a plan for ârubbish collection, illegal dumping and cleaner public spacesâ.

7. Help us hustle

The SACP proposes municipal decent work plans covering infrastructure maintenance, food production, recycling, care work, community safety and local production. It backs worker and consumer cooperatives, village agricultural cooperatives and community-owned stores. Informal traders and platform workers should be âprotected and free to organiseâ. Procurement should build local capacity.

The partyâs local economy is built around public employment, cooperatives and local procurement rather than private investment and deregulation.

Verdict: Good. But who pays for it and how is it funded?

8. A home for everyone

Municipal land should be audited and protected from capture, then used for housing, food production, cooperatives and community facilities.

The SACP promises well-located social and affordable housing.

Verdict: Again, the emphasis is not primarily on housing numbers, but on who controls urban land and what it is used for. This is so important. Municipal land has become subjected to two trends: it goes to the highest bidder or it is part of patronage network extraction.

9. Break the nyaope curse

The manifesto discusses primary healthcare, community safety and social infrastructure, but does not set out a municipal strategy for drugs and addiction.

Verdict: Thereâs no plan.

10. Give us a city worth living in

This is where the manifesto is stronger again. It describes sport, arts, culture and public facilities as âessential social infrastructure, not luxuriesâ.

SACP councillors would hold regular, open ward assemblies. They must give monthly ward feedback and âaccept recall if they betray the manifestoâ. âA seat in council is a post of struggle and service, not a career or a business opportunity.â

Verdict: We love this.

Reality check

The manifesto is filled with revolutionary zeal and local peopleâs power. In that sense, itâs refreshing. General secretary Solly MaÂpaila coined the use of the phrase âstate captureâ locally, so the anatomy of local corruption is well tracked and well known. But it lacks real-world experience of balancing budgets and competing priorities. DM

This story first appeared in our weekly DM168 newspaper, available countrywide for R35.

Reporting originally appeared via Daily Maverick. Read the full source for additional context.